Dashboard/Keir Starmer/Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg at Labour conference: the polls, Reform, asylum, digital ID, VAT and his leadership
Interview · 28 Sep 2025
Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg at Labour conference: the polls, Reform, asylum, digital ID, VAT and his leadership
Video: YouTube: BBC News (official channel). Retrieved 9 Oct 2026.
Some bluff & spinProvisional
246 sentences · 29 checked claims · 34 questions
Answers questions
56%
34 questions rated. Answered = 1, Partly answered and Declined openly = ½, Dodged = 0.
Answered 11Partly answered 13Declined openly 3Dodged 7
Laura Kuenssberg
Well, Prime Minister, welcome to the program. How much trouble are you in?
DodgedAsked how much trouble he is in. Lists the government's record on NHS appointments, childcare, the Hillsborough law and frigates and says he understands frustration, without addressing his own position.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
That's a different thing than you admitting that you are in quite a bit of political trouble. The very latest opinion poll suggests if there were an election right now, Labor would have fewer than a hundred seats. So, how much trouble are you in?
DodgedPressed with a poll suggesting Labour would win fewer than 100 seats. Says Labour won a mandate last July, without addressing the question.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
How much trouble are you in right now?
DodgedAsked again how much trouble he is in right now. Says change takes time and the government will be judged at the next election.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
I'm asking you about the situation right now because there are a lot of people in your own party coming here to Liverpool who really worry about what's been going on. Do you accept that you are in political trouble, Laura?
Partly answeredAsked whether he accepts he is in political trouble. Says comments about leaders are normal at conference time, which implies he does not, without saying yes or no.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
There aren't always polls that put the governing party so far behind.
DodgedTold that polls do not always put a governing party so far behind. Turns to what the government is delivering and the Hillsborough law.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
And you've mentioned that already. So, let's let's talk about what else you're going to be talking about in the next few days. You've already admitted many people in the public are impatient and they're angry. Your answer is to call reform the enemy and promise patriotic renewal. What does that mean in brass tax?
AnsweredAsked what 'patriotic renewal' means in practice. Gives examples on growth across the country, the NHS and the Pride in Place funding, and explains why he calls Reform a threat.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
But for many people there has been concern about what's going on in this country because of immigration. And you yourself said on Friday that the left got it wrong on illegal immigration. When did you realize you'd got it wrong?
Partly answeredAsked when he realised the left got illegal immigration wrong. Says he thought so 'for some time' before being cut off.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
when did you realize that?
AnsweredPressed on when. Says soon after he became a politician, when people told him their concerns.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
What did you do about it then?
Partly answeredAsked what he did about it then. Says he spent nine years in opposition, then lists measures since taking office in 2024, rather than anything he did at the time.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Have you ever been to see an asylum hotel?
AnsweredAsked whether he has ever visited an asylum hotel. Says yes.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Do you think when you went there when you went to which community? Can you tell us?
DodgedAsked which community he visited, and told the pledge to empty hotels runs to 2029. Does not name a place and speaks about emptying hotels and the inherited backlog; says only he would like to bring the date forward.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
But will you commit to bringing that forward?
Partly answeredAsked to commit to bringing the 2029 date forward. Says claims must be processed and he is looking at alternative accommodation, without making the commitment.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
But what about what's happening right now? Because you have been in power now for 14 months. This is not you haven't just walked through the door of number 10. Is it fair for asylum seekers to have taxis paid for them by the taxpayer to go to doctor's appointments sometimes hundreds of miles away? Is that fair?
AnsweredAsked whether it is fair for asylum seekers to get taxis paid for by the taxpayer to distant appointments. Says no.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Will you stop it immediately?
Partly answeredAsked whether he will stop it immediately. Says it will be stopped 'as soon as we can', not immediately.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Is it fair for asylum seekers to be allowed to appeal more than once? Of course, the right of appeal is part of our justice system, but as things stand, assigned speakers can appeal more than once if they are told they have to leave the country.
Partly answeredAsked whether it is fair for asylum seekers to appeal more than once. Says he wants to look at rights of appeal and gives examples of late claims, without saying whether it is fair.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Um one of our viewers got in touch and wanted us to ask this question. Russ Brown wanted us to ask you if you really believe that those profiting from human trafficking will think oh dear I have to check your digital ID now I can't carry on paying you1 pound50 an hour to work in my sweat shop.
Partly answeredA viewer asks whether exploitative employers will really check digital ID. Says illegal working draws people to the UK and must be tackled, without saying why such employers would comply.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
bosses who are prepared to hire people illegally are not asking them for their national insurance card. So what's the evidence? What makes you think they're suddenly going to ask them for a digital ID?
Partly answeredAsked for evidence that employers who ignore National Insurance checks would ask for a digital ID. Points to more raids and the scale of illegal working, not to evidence that employers would comply.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Why do you think that them having a digital ID, having to have a digital ID would stop that problem when right now people are meant to have a national insurance number and card and if they're not asked for that a boss is willing already to break the rules? What's the difference going to be?
AnsweredAsked what difference digital ID would make. Says it is checked at the start of a job and collected automatically, so the government knows who is working.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
And you're presenting all of this in a a a sort of ideology, I suppose, an ideological point that you're making now that we are in a new battle and that your party is up against an extreme party. You're sort of representing the mainstream as the extreme. You mentioned your grave concern about the reform policy potentially to deport people who already live here. Do you think that's an immoral policy?
AnsweredAsked whether Reform's plan to deport people already lawfully here is immoral. Says yes and explains why.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
You said that proposal is immoral to deport people who are already here if they don't pass more stringent rules. Do you think it's a racist policy?
AnsweredAsked whether the policy is racist. Says yes.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
And do you think that Reform UK is trying to appeal to racists?
AnsweredAsked whether Reform UK is trying to appeal to racists. Says no, and describes its voters as frustrated with slow change.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
for 14 months if for 14 months prime minister they've heard politicians and people in your government promise things and then they see so little change they are looking for somewhere else and if we look for one of the things that you are announcing at this conference your proposal to build new towns for example you're promising to build a dozen new towns but when you look in detail at the policy the number of new towns you're saying there will be by 2029, 5 years after you won the election, it's three. And even those three places might still not get built because they have to go through all sorts of checks. So people look at that and hear that and think you're not getting anything done. It's too timid. There's no urgency.
Partly answeredTold only three new towns are due by 2029 and the approach seems timid. Restates the 1.5 million homes target, blames planning lag and says change takes time, without addressing the three-towns figure.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
You didn't You did say it would take time, but what you in your party did not expect was this precipitous fall off a cliff in terms of your popularity. Leaders can be popular in hard times, and you're admitting there are hard times still, but your popularity has taken such a knock. And the country's finances are incredibly tight. There's huge pressure on public money, a budget coming up. Will you rule out raising VAT?
Declined openlyAsked whether he will rule out raising VAT. Answers the point about popularity, then says he will not set out what is in the November Budget.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
dozens and dozens and dozens of occasions you ruled out raising VAT. It's in the solemn document of your party's manifesto. You're the prime minister of this country. Can you rule out raising VAT?
Partly answeredAsked again to rule out raising VAT. Repeats that 'the manifesto stands' and the commitments will not be unpicked, without saying in terms that VAT will not rise.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
well well you can it's a different thing saying the manifesto stands right now or you saying actually it will stand in perpetuity. You're not going to unpick those promises.
Declined openlyAsked whether the promises stand for good, not just now. Repeats that the manifesto stands and says no Prime Minister would set out the Budget two months early.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Well, hang on. Can you be crystal clear there because you're saying the manifesto stands right now, but I'm not going to talk about budget. This is something you've ruled out dozens and dozens and dozens of times. You're ruling it out clearly right now.
Partly answeredAsked whether he is ruling a VAT rise out clearly. Says the manifesto stands and he stands by its commitments, without a plain yes.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
There's another issue that many people are worried about, which is special needs education for children because the government's reviewing how it's provided. The system has had many problems over the years. So, we don't need to outline the problems over the years. But would you rule out scrapping the legal right for children who need help with special needs at school?
Partly answeredAsked to rule out scrapping the legal right to special needs support. Says he does not want to take away rights but the system must be reformed, without ruling it out.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
so you might scrap that legal right.
Declined openlyPut to him that he might scrap the right. Says he is not indicating that, but no final decisions are made and he cannot set out proposals yet.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
I know many parents and charities will be listening to the details of your answer very closely there. And before we move on, I just want to clarify something for the record. There's more detail in reporting for the from the Sunday Times today about a piece of land you bought for your parents many years ago. Did you put it into a trust?
AnsweredAsked whether he put the field he bought for his parents into a trust. Says no, and explains why he bought it.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
and that's now on the record. You did not put it in trust and that's not been on the record before and that is now on the record. What's Sandy Barnham up to?
DodgedAsked what Andy Burnham is up to. Says he is doing a good job as mayor and they work closely, without addressing the leadership manoeuvring the question points to.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
the first to say but not the only person to say that there are issues with your leadership. His colleague in London Sadi Khan said he'd been raising legitimate concerns and the point about this is that although I know it's awkward for you to talk about leadership if you don't have the 100% confidence of your party you can't get the things done that you want to do.
Partly answeredTold that without his party's full confidence he cannot get things done. Says comments on leadership come with the job, then turns to NHS appointments and jobs.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
Think about what's happened in parliament. You've had to ditch some of your big plans because you couldn't carry your party with you. Think about why some people in your party are desperately worried about what's going on because you have been miles behind in the polls for month after month after month. I've spoken to a lot of people in the Labor Party in the last few months about this and there is wide and deep concern about the way in which you're doing your job. Is it wise to stick your fingers in and say pa leadership's just what happens?
AnsweredAsked whether it is wise to brush off his party's concerns. Says no, people are entitled to their views and he is not ignoring them, and explains his focus on delivery.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
But prime minister, if people in your party and the public, which we can see through the polls, look at that list and look at you and think we don't have much faith in that. We don't have that much faith in what this man is doing on our behalf. What if, Prime Minister, the problem is you?
DodgedAsked what if the problem is him. Says he will be judged at the next election on living standards, public services and security, without addressing whether he is the problem.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
Laura Kuenssberg
One of your Labor predecessors when he was having a bit of bother, Harold Wilson, when asked what was going on with his leadership, he said, "I tell you what's going on. This government's going on and I'm going on." And John Major said to his critics, "Put up or shut up." What's Kier Star saying? Give me time. Give me space.
AnsweredAsked what his message to critics is, compared with Wilson and Major. Says the party faces the fight of its life against Reform and it is not the time for navel-gazing.Our model rated this
Not yet reviewed by a person
1 further exchange(s) not rated: procedural or ceremonial questions (a tribute, thanks or condolence that asks for nothing), or questions the speaker did not take.